Now taking your Christmas 2020 orders. Orders must be prepaid. Order by Tues., Dec. 15th for both Thursday, Dec. 24th pickup or Wednesday, Dec. 23rd pickup. Open Mon., Dec. 21st, 9am-5pm and Christmas Eve, 8am-2pm. Closed Christmas Day and Sat., Dec. 26th.
Due to Covid and the volume of orders at this time of year, order restrictions apply. Minimum quantities will be required to place prepaid orders. We reserve the right to close out orders early due to high volume. We reserve the right to limit quantities purchase at one time with out a preorder. Ask our sales staff for specific ordering requirements.
Traditional Christmas Buche De Noel Cakes – $29 each serves 8-10 (quantities limited)
Traditional Christmas Swiss Roll style filled cake now available in 2 cake flavors and 2 styles!
Chocolate Cake Buche De Noel
filled with fresh whipped cream, covered in chocolate fudge ganache and decorated like a traditional Yule log with holly leaves and berries.
White Cake Buche De Noel
filled with fresh whipped cream, covered in Sparking vanilla butter cream, decorated with holly leaves and berries.
Assorted Fruit, Cream and Specialty Pies – 10” deep dish size $15.75 each
Apple, Apple Crumb, Pumpkin, Strawberry Rhubarb, Very Berry, Blueberry, Cherry, Toll House, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream.
Pecan Pie – $19.99.
Assorted Cheesecakes New York Style – 8” – $39 or 10” – $49
Lemon Ricotta – 10” – $49
Cherry, Blueberry or Chocolate Ganache topped NYS Cheesecakes – 8”- $49 or 10” – $59
Specialty Layer Cakes (6” or 8” or 10” sizes) from $28 (quantities limited)
Cookies & Cream Cake, Reese’s Cake, Ultimate Chocolate Cake, Italian Cream Cake, Rum Cake, Tiramisu Cake, Strawberry & Cream Cake, Red Velvet Cake, Black Forest Cake & more!
Small, $29 Grand, $39 Super Grand, $49
Cookie Sampler Box -1 lb. $19.99 each (no substitutions on cookie boxes)
Italian Pastry Platters – Includes Lobster Tails, Cream Puffs, Éclairs, Lemon Bars, Brownie Bites and Cannoli. (no substitutions). Starting at $29, serves 8-10 people.
Increasing in $10 increments for every 4-6 additional servings. Larger pastries are cut into small pieces and placed in decorative cups on trays to increase your serving count!
Gluten Free Cookie Gift Box – $22.99 See GF section for selection (no substitutions)
Traditional American Cookie Platters – $29 includes 30 assorted chocolate chip, oatmeal scotchies, gingersnap, snickerdoodle, and sugar cookies. (no substitutions)
Holiday Frosted Cutout Cookies, vanilla shapes or gingerbread men – starting at $3 each (minimum order is 1 dozen assorted Christmas shaped vanilla cutouts and/or gingerbread men)
Black and White Cookies – $3 each
Jumbo Christmas Cupcakes – Christmas Tree, Snowman, Santa and more – $5 each
Holiday Deluxe Cookies To Decorate Kits – $29 each, contains 15 unfrosted cookies, frosting and decorations. Available in store and on our website at CookiesToDecorate.com
Specialty Breads and Sweet Breads
Panettone Bread – $7.95 each
Challah Bread – $7.95 each
Polish Placek Bread – $7.95 each
Assorted Sweet Breads – choose Pumpkin Bread, Gingerbread, Cranberry Crumb Bread or Coffee Cake Bread – $5.25 each
Specialty Breakfast Cakes and Brunch Selections
Sour Cream Streusel Coffee Cakes – 11” size $39 each 7” size $19 each
Cinnamon Bun 6 –packs – $12.99 per tray
Zucchini and Roasted Red Pepper 10” Quiche – $18.99 each
Potato, Bacon and Cheddar 10” Quiche – $18.99 each
Assorted Scones – $2.25 each Gluten Free Scones – $2.75 each
Choose Blueberry, Lemon, Chocolate Chip, Cranberry Peach, and Gluten Free varieties (blueberry, lemon, cinnamon raisin).
Assorted Turnovers – $3.50 each
Choose from Apple and Cherry fruit turnovers (vegan), or Savory filled with Spinach, Garlic, Ricotta cheese and Romano cheese turnover.
Lobster Tails and Sfogliatelle – prices vary
Cannoli – Small $2.75 each Large $3.75 each
Cream Puffs (whipped cream filled) – $2.25 each
Éclairs (pastry cream filled) – $2.25 each
Gluten Free Specialties or Vegan Specialties
Gluten Free White, Chocolate, or Marble Cakes – starting at $35 each
Vegan and Gluten Free Chocolate Cake – starting at $35 each
Gluten Free Jumbo White Cupcakes – $5 each
Gluten Free and Vegan Jumbo Chocolate Cupcakes – $5 each
Gluten Free Frosted Cutout Cookies – $3.00 each
Gluten Free Chocolate Brownies – $2.00 each
Gluten Free White Cake Bon Bons – $2.50 each
Gluten Free French Macarons – $2 each
Gluten Free Chocolate Dipped Almond Rounds – $1 each
Gluten Free Amoretti Cookies – $1 each
Gluten Free Scones – blueberry, lemon and cinnamon raisin $2.75 each
GF Cheesecake Varieties – 8” size, starting at $39, 10” size starting at $49
GF Mini NYS Cheesecakes – $3.50 each
Quiche Varieties – 10” size, $18.99 each – Choose zucchini and roasted red pepper or potato, bacon and cheddar flavors.
Christmas Gluten Free Cookie Box Assortment (12 Ct) – $22.99 each
(includes White Cake Bon Bons, Amoretti, Almond Rounds and/or French Macaroons (no substitutions))
Deluxe Cookies To Decorate Kits – $29 kit! No Time To Bake?
Decorate our baked Christmas cutouts at home with your family! Many kits available, each with 15 unfrosted baked cookies, frosting, decorations and more per kit. Check out CookiesToDecorate.com for kit designs and more! Available as an in-store pickup as well. No local deliveries during the holidays on kits.