Fill out the form below to get more information about our Holiday Specials. To place an order, please call the bakery.
Now taking your Christmas 2025 prepaid orders. Last day to place Christmas orders is Wednesday, December 17th.
Open Christmas Eve, Wednesday, December 24th, 9am-1:30pm and New Years Eve, Wednesday, December 31st, 9am-1:30pm.
We will be closed Christmas Day, December 26th, New Years Day and January 2nd.
Due to the order volume at this time of year, order restrictions apply. Minimum quantities will be required to place prepaid orders. We reserve the right to close out orders early due to high volume. We reserve the right to limit in store quantities purchased at one time without a minimum 72 hour prepaid order. Ask our sales staff for specific ordering requirements. All sales are final. No cancellations, refunds or exchanges.
The Bakery will close for staff lunch and case restocking from 1:30-2:30pm Tuesday-Friday, December 9-12th, Tuesday-Friday, December 15-19th, and December 22nd. We reopen at 2:30pm to resume the day. There will be no pickups during this time as the lobby will be closed. We appreciate your understanding as the staff is working incredibly long hours.
Traditional Christmas Buche De Noel Cakes - $39 each (serves 8-10, quantities limited)
Traditional Christmas Swiss Roll style filled cake now available in 2 cake flavors and 2 styles!
Chocolate Cake Buche De Noel - Filled with fresh whipped cream, frosted in chocolate fudge ganache and decorated with holly leaves and berries.
Vanilla Cake Buche De Noel - Filled with fresh whipped cream, frosted in vanilla buttercream and decorated with holly leaves and berries.
Assorted Fruit, Cream and Specialty Pies - $17.75 each (10" deep dish size)
Apple, Apple Crumb, Pumpkin, Very Berry, Toll House, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream and Peanut Butter Cream.
Assorted Cheesecakes
New York Style - 8” for $49 or 10” for $59
Lemon Ricotta - 10” for $69
Cherry Compote or Chocolate Ganache topped NYS Cheesecakes - 8” for $55 or 10” for $65
Chocolate, Pumpkin or Baileys Cheesecakes - 10” size only for $75
Specialty Layer Cakes - Starting at $35 each (6", 8", or 10", quantities limited)
Cookies & Cream Cake, Reese's Cake, Ultimate Chocolate Cake, Italian Cream Cake, Rum Cake, Tiramisu Cake, Strawberry & Cream Cake, Red Velvet Cake, Black Forest Cake and more!
Grand Christmas Italian Cookie Platters - (no substitutions on cookie platters)
Small (28 Cookies) - $29.95 each
Grand (44 Cookies) - $39.95 each
Italian Cookie Sampler Box - $24.00 each (no substitutions on cookie boxes)
Italian Pastry Boxes - Includes Lobster Tails, Cream Puffs, Éclairs, Sfogliatelle and Cannoli (no substitutions).
Small (Serves 8-10) - $39.95 each
Large (Serves 12-16) - $49.95 each
Gluten Free Cookie Gift Box - $24.95 each
Includes White Cake Bon Bons, Amoretti, Almond Rounds and/or French Macaroons (no substitutions).
Traditional American Cookie Platters - $39.95 each
Includes 30 assorted chocolate chip, oatmeal scotchies , gingersnap, snickerdoodle, chocolate m&m, and sugar cookies (no substitutions).
Holiday Frosted Cutout Cookies - Starting at $3.25 each
Vanilla shapes or gingerbread men (minimum order is 1 dozen assorted Christmas shaped vanilla cutouts and/or gingerbread men).
Black and White Cookies - $3.50 each
Chocolate Chip Whoopie Pies - $4 each
Cinnamon Buns - 4 pack $11.95 each or 6 pack $14.95 each
Assorted Danish - 4 pack $12.95 each
Deluxe Holiday Cookies To Decorate Kits - $29.95 each
Contains 15 unfrosted cookies, frosting and decorations. Available in store and on our website at CookiesToDecorate.com.
Paint Your Own Cookies To Decorate Kits - $10.95 (3 count) or $21.90 (6 count)
All kits contain frosted cutouts with holiday designs ready to decorate with enclosed paint pallet and paint brush.
In Store Shopping Guidelines
Please note we have limited the purchase of certain in store items without a 72 hour prepaid order. This includes the following items:
Frosted Cutouts - 2 dozen maximum, boxed only.
Italian Cookie Platters - Maximum 4.
Italian Cookie Sampler Box - Maximum 4.
American Cookie Platters - Maximum 4
Bagged Biscotti - Maximum 4.
We are unable to provide custom platters of cookies or pastries for in-store purchase, but you may select various items in our cases and they will be boxed and wrapped with a holiday ribbon.
