Now taking Thanksgiving Day orders! All order pickups on Wednesday, November 26th, 2025. All orders must be prepaid.
Thanksgiving Extended Hours:
Open Monday, November 24th: 9am-5pm
Closed Thanksgiving Day, November 27th
Open Friday, November 28th: 11am-5pm
Last day to place Thanksgiving Day orders is 1pm, Friday, November 21, 2025. We reserve the right to close out orders early due to high volume and to limit quantities purchased in store without a preorder. Ask us for specific ordering guidelines/requirements. All sales are final, no refunds, exchanges, cancellations or after hours/late pickups.
Fruit Pies, Cream Pies, Specialty Pies - Starting at $17.75 each
10” deep dish size
Choose Apple, Apple Crumb, Pumpkin, Cherry, Strawberry Rhubarb, Very Berry, Toll House, Peanut Butter Cream, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, and Coconut Cream.
Cheesecakes
New York Style - 8” - $49 or 10” - $59
Lemon Ricotta - 10” - $69
Chocolate, Pumpkin or Baileys Cheesecakes - 8” - $65 or 10” - $75
Specialty Layer Cakes (6”-10” sizes) - Starting at $34
Ginger Molasses Cake, Salted Caramel Cake, Ultimate Chocolate Cake, Italian Cream Cake, Pumpkin Spice Cake, Chocolate Blackout Cake, Italian Rum Cake, Tiramisu Cake, Cookies & Cream Cake, Boston Cream Cake, Black Forest Cake and more!
Italian and American Cookie Platters and Pastry Boxes
Italian Cookie Sampler Box - $24 (no substitutions)
American Cookie Platter - 30 count - $39.95 (no substitutions)
Gluten Free Holiday Assortment Box - 12 count - $24.95 (no substitutions)
Pastry Boxes - Includes Sfogliatelle, Lobster Tails, Cream Puffs, Éclairs and Cannoli - Small Box (serves 8-10) $39.95 Grand Box (serves 14-20) $49.95 (no substitutions)
Italian Cookie Platters - Small $29.95 Grand $39.95 (no substitutions)
Specialty Thanksgiving Cutout Cookies
Frosted Cutout Cookies, vanilla or ginger bread favors - Starting at $3.50 each
Gluten Free Frosted Vanilla Cutouts - Starting at $3.50 each
Giant Frosted Pumpkin Spice Cookies - $3.50 each
Black and White Cookies - $3.50 each
Pumpkin Spice Whoopie Pies with maple buttercream filling - $4 each
Thanksgiving Deluxe Cookies to Decorate Kits - $29.95 each
Frost cookies at home with kids! Kits include 15 baked cutouts, 4 bags colored icing, 4 bags colored sprinkles, decorating instructions and ideas. Check out CookiesToDecorate.com for all our Deluxe Cookie Kits.
Paint Your Own (PYO) Thanksgiving Cookie Decorating Kits - $10.95 each
Our newest cookie decorating kits contain three vanilla frosted cookies with a paintable B/W image printed on each, a colorful paint pallet (water activated) with 6 colors, mini paint brush, directions and brochure. Images include a happy turkey, Thanksgiving pies and cornucopia themes. This is a perfect kit for all ages. Kits will also be available at the bakery for purchase. Check out CookiesToDecorate.com for all of our PYO kits available including Christmas, Winter, Hannukah and more festive kit themes.
Novelty Thanksgiving Day Cake - Starting at $39
6” size, complete with fondant turkey slices, whipped buttercream mashed potatoes with butter, candy peas and carrots & ganache gravy! So fun, so delicious! Larger cake sizes available. Call for pricing!
Specialty Breakfast and Brunch Selections
Cinnamon Buns - $11.95 (4 count) or $14.95 (6 count)
Assorted Danish - $12.95 (4 count) - Apple, Cherry, Cheese, Raspberry Cheese
Zucchini and Roasted Red Pepper 10” Quiche - $25 each
Potato and Cheddar 10” Quiche - $25 each
Assorted Scones - $3.50 each (egg free)
Choose Blueberry, Lemon, Chocolate Chip, and Cranberry Peach.
Assorted Turnovers
Apple or Vegan Cherry - $3.50 each
Savory Spinach and Garlic with Romano and Ricotta Cheese - $4.00 each
Pastries
Lobster Tails and Sfogliatelle - Prices vary
Cannoli - Small $2.95 each - Large $3.95 each
Cream Puffs (whipped cream filled) - $2.95 each
Éclairs - $2.95 each
Croissants - $4 each
Almondine Pastry - $4 each
Gluten Free (GF) and Vegan (V) Specialties
Gluten Free White, Chocolate and Marble Cakes - Starting at $42
Vegan Chocolate Cake Varieties - Starting at $42 or Jumbo Cupcake $5.95 each
Gluten Free White or Chocolate Jumbo Cupcakes - $5.95 each
Gluten Free Frosted Cutout Cookies - $3.75 each
Assorted Cake Bon Bons (GF) - $2.75 each
Brownies (GF) - $2.50 each
Gluten Free French Macaroons - $2.50 each
Almond Rounds (GF) - $1.25 each
Amoretti Cookies (GF) - $1.25 each
Gluten Free Holiday Assortment Box - 12 count - $24.95 each (no substitutions)
Cheesecake Varieties (GF) - 8” starting at $49 or 10” starting at $59
Cheesecakes Mini (GF) - $4.25 each, NY style and seasonal flavors
Quiche Varieties (GF) choose Zucchini and Roasted Red Pepper or Potato and Cheddar (crust free) - 10” size, $25 each
Lemon or Blueberry Scones (GF and Egg Free) - $3.50 each
Deluxe Cookies to Decorate Kits - $29.95 kit
No Time to Bake? Decorate our baked Holiday Cutouts at home with your family! Many kits available, each with 15 unfrosted baked cookies, 4 icing bags, 4 bags sprinkles and more per kit!
Also available Gluten Free - $34.95 kit
Check out CookiesToDecorate.com for all our Deluxe Cookie Kit themes and our new Paint Your Own (PYO) Cookie Decorating kits and more! Choose in store pickup or shipping across the USA. Makes the perfect gift for family & friends.
